is it illegal to dumpster dive in minnesota

Is It Illegal to Dumpster Dive in Minnesota? Law Guide

No, it is not illegal in Minnesota to dumpster dive. No law prohibits trash searching. The legal exposure is with the location of the dumpster. Diving behind a fenced or posted business or refusing to leave when asked to do so is a misdemeanor under Minnesota Statute 609.605. Under another city ordinance, Minneapolis prohibits residents from putting recyclables out for city pickup. Public-property diving, on the other hand, has a solid legal foundation due to a 1988 U.S. Supreme Court decision.

Key Takeaways

  • There is no state statute in Minnesota that specifically mentions or prohibits dumpster diving.
  • Trespass is covered by Minnesota Statute 609.605 and occurs as soon as a diver enters fenced, locked or posted private property without permission.
  • In California v. Greenwood, the Supreme Court ruled in 1988 that trash that is collected by the garbage man in the public area is not protected by a reasonable expectation of privacy, a rule that is followed by courts across the country.
  • Minneapolis Ordinance 244.355(c) prohibits the removal of recyclables that are placed for pick-up by the City, without regard to any trespass issues.
  • Items taken from a locked or sealed dumpster can be used to support a theft charge as the contents may not be abandoned.
  • The majority of the trespass offenses related to dumpster diving in Minnesota are misdemeanors, though if a warning is ignored and it is repeated, the consequences can escalate.

What is Minnesota Law, Anyway, About Dumpster Diving?

No legislation has been passed in Minnesota that mentions dumpster diving specifically. The state does not consider searching through garbage to be a crime. It is not the search that is illegal, but where the dumpster is located and how the container is handled.

This model is derived from a federal case. The U.S. Supreme Court in California v. Greenwood (1988) ruled that a person who puts trash in a public place waives his or her reasonable expectation of privacy in the trash. It can be searched by law enforcement without a warrant, and thus, by a private citizen. The moment an item is in a public collection point, Minnesota will consider it abandoned, and the thrower will no longer have a property interest in the item. It is that principle that makes it so that it is OK to dive off the curb and not OK to dive behind a locked commercial enclosure.

How Minnesota’s Trespass Law Applies to Dumpster Diving

Most disputes over dumpster diving in Minnesota are governed by Minnesota Statutes Section 609.605, which is the general trespass statute. It doesn’t talk about dumpsters or waste, but anyone who enters a posted, fenced or otherwise restricted property without permission and refuses to leave when asked to do so.

Minnesota trespasses when someone enters or stays on someone else’s property after being told to go or after entering a locked or posted enclosure without permission or when someone returns to a property after being warned not to.

A dumpster behind a retail store, restaurant or apartment complex is typically located on private property. The elements of trespass are satisfied by a diver’s climbing over or around the fence, gated, or marked with a no trespassing sign property under Section 609.605. The majority of trespass offenses under this section are misdemeanors, and the fines are usually accompanied by the potential for short jail time, but can escalate to felony if the trespasser has a prior trespass conviction or damages property.

If an employee or property owner gives a verbal warning, it is legally binding, even if not posted. A refusal by a person in authority to a diver to leave the property may be sufficient to establish a charge of trespass in itself if the diver remains on the property or returns later.

Where is the Dumpster located, Public or Private Property?

The one question that is most critical for any Minnesota diver to ask before searching a container.

Dumpster Location Typical Legal Status in Minnesota
Curbside trash set out for municipal pickup Generally treated as abandoned; lowest legal risk
Open, unfenced commercial dumpster visible from a public sidewalk Often tolerated, but the lot itself may still be private property
Dumpster behind a fence, gate, or “No Trespassing” sign Entry without permission risks a Section 609.605 trespass charge
Locked or padlocked dumpster Forcing entry risks both trespass and theft exposure
Dumpster on apartment or HOA property Treated as private property; nonresidents need permission

Is it Theft in Minnesota to Take Items From a Dumpster?

Trespass isn’t necessarily the only charge that a diver can be charged with. When a dumpster is locked, sealed or otherwise secured, there may be no legal abandonment of the contents. If a diver forces open a lock or breaks a seal to retrieve items, they may also be guilty of theft or criminal damage, as well as trespass, because by opening the lock or seal the owner was asserting his or her right to keep the contents.

Unlocked dumpsters are a much less dangerous option on this front. When trash is left in an open container for collection, generally Minnesota follows the abandonment principle of Greenwood. The distinction is whether the owner took visible measures, locks, fences, signs, etc., to ensure the contents are under his/her control.

Also See: Is It Illegal to Dumpster Dive in Arizona

On Recyclables: There’s a rule here in Minneapolis

A layer that state law does not cover is added to the largest city in Minnesota. The City of Minneapolis does not accept recyclables that residents have placed out for the city’s collection. This is an unauthorized removal (also referred to as “scavenging”) which is a violation under City of Minneapolis Ordinance 244.355(c), apart from any trespass issue. According to the city’s own guidance, this is recycling theft and that it has an impact on the city’s recycling revenue and program costs.

This is important because it is not limited to the case where the recycling bin is placed at the curb on a public street, which is where general trespass law would not apply. Even a diver who is “clean” on a curbside trash bag could find themselves in violation of this ordinance if they take items from a marked recycling cart. St. Paul also has codes that regulate the maintenance of the property, and solid waste disposal of containers, although its main program is administered by the city’s Public Works department, not a scavenging ordinance.

Is It Unlawful To Dumpster Dive at Sephora or Other Retail Stores in Minnesota?

In almost all cases, retail store dumpsters, such as those located behind a Sephora, Target, or other stores, are located on private, commercial property. Whether it’s a retailer or another, the same trespass analysis is used.

Where the dumpster is located in an unenclosed area without a fence, gate or posted sign and employees have no objections, the legal exposure is the same as for any other open commercial dumpster. Entering a fenced loading area, behind a locked gate, or signage marked is sufficient to meet the elements of trespass under Section 609.605. The risk to a diver who is asked to leave by store staff and who refuses to leave is the same regardless of which store owns the dumpster. There is no statute that specifically mentions any one retail brand; it’s always a question of whether the property is private and whether the diver had permission to be there.

Health and Safety Issues Unique to Minnesota

Legal risk isn’t the only thing to consider. The practical aspects of dumpster diving are also influenced by the safety of the food and the weather in Minnesota.

  • Cold weather exposure. Minnesota winters have longer periods of freezing temperatures. A metal lid or handle on a dumpster can lead to frostbite on uncovered skin and snow or ice near loading docks can create a slip hazard.
  • Food safety. Minnesota Department of Agriculture and local health departments regulate food handling at retail and food service establishments, but those regulations are for the business and not the person who is picking up the thrown-away food. Food removed from a commercial dumpster has almost always come from outside of any temperature-controlled environment and may be at risk of spoilage or contamination.
  • Sharp and sharp objects. There are many items in commercial waste streams that can cause injury and do not need to be a subject of dispute.
  • No civil remedy for sickness. If a diver gets sick from a food item that has been retrieved, he or she typically does not have a legal cause of action against the business that discarded the food because the food was no longer in a sale or service.

A Quick Reference: What’s OK and What’s Not OK

Generally allowed in Minnesota:

  • Visiting unlocked receptacles for public pickup at the curb to look for trash
  • Removing goods from an unfenced and unmarked commercial dumpster that is exposed to the public sidewalk, without the owner’s consent to the removal.
  • Requesting permission from a business owner to go through their dumpster

Generally banned in Minnesota:

  • Climbing a fence, opening a gate or entering a posted area to gain access to a dumpster
  • Staying on private land after being told to go away.Staying on private land when told to leave.
  • Unlocking or opening a locked dumpster or padlocked dumpster.
  • Minneapolis recycles 80% of its trash by separating recyclables from the rest of the waste stream.In Minneapolis, 80% of trash is recycled by separating recyclables from the waste stream.
  • When a trespass warning is issued, if the property is returned, the warning will be removed.

This report compares Minnesota’s results to those of other states

The Minnesota approach is fairly representative of the upper Midwest. It does not have a statewide ban on dumpster diving, it’s based on a general trespass statute as most states are, and it adds city-specific rules where local government has decided to intervene.

State State-Level Approach Notable Local Rule
Minnesota No statewide ban; Minn. Stat. 609.605 trespass applies Minneapolis Ordinance 244.355(c) bans recycling scavenging
Iowa No statewide ban; Iowa Code 716.7 trespass applies No confirmed citywide scavenging bans in major cities
Illinois No statewide ban; trespass and local scavenging rules apply Some municipalities restrict open waste scavenging
Texas No statewide ban; trespass law applies Local scavenging restrictions vary by city

In almost every state, the act of searching through garbage is lawful in theory, but trespass law takes care of the specifics of where it can be done.

Also Read: Is It Illegal To

Conclusion

There is no law in Minnesota that makes dumpster diving illegal. The legal line is not in waste law, but in property law. Trespass is governed by Minnesota Statutes Section 609.605, and is triggered when a diver enters over a fence, past a posted sign, or when asked to leave. There is another narrower rule in Minneapolis, Ordinance 244.355(c), which protects recyclables placed out for city pickup, which is not based on trespass concerns.

The best way to be on the right side of the law is simple. Search only open, unlocked containers on land that is clearly public or with no fence, gate or posted warning. Do not open locked dumpsters. Wait for permission to enter any enclosed commercial space. And in Minneapolis, leave curbside recycling carts untouched. Local regulations may also change over time, and it is always best to check a city’s current municipal code before assuming any general summary, such as this one.

To learn more about dumpster diving laws, check out Is It Illegal to Dumpster Dive?

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Does the Minnesota Legislature consider dumpster diving to be illegal?

There is no statute in Minnesota that prohibits dumpster diving. The risk of being found legally is not the risk of searching through trash, but the risk of trespassing on private property.

2. If I am caught dumpster diving on private property in Minnesota, what is the penalty?

The trespass most frequently used in these cases is Minnesota Statutes Section 609.605. It is used when someone enters private property without permission, after it’s been fenced or locked, or when they are told to leave, but they don’t.

3. May I be fined for removing items from a Minneapolis curbside bin that are meant for recycling?

Yes. This occurs on public property at the curb, but is prohibited under City of Minneapolis Ordinance 244.355(c) from taking recyclable materials that have been set out for authorized city collection.

4. Is it illegal to take items from a locked dumpster in Minnesota?

A locked dumpster is a sign that the owner has not abandoned the contents, and will be considered a crime of theft or property damage if the lock is broken and someone steals the contents or damages the property.

5. Would I be allowed to dumpster dive behind a store in Minnesota?

Explicit permission is not legally required, but is the safest course of action, if the dumpster is on open, unfenced ground with no signage. If fenced, gated or marked, consent of the property owner must be obtained or a trespass charge is liable to be issued.

6. Can you dumpster dive at Sephora or other stores in Minnesota?

All retailers are subject to the same trespass laws. Low legal risk is an open, unmarked, unfenced dumpster; no legal risk is a fenced, locked or posted enclosure, regardless of who owns it.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *